I thought he was awful.
The first free kick he gave to us (apart from an offside, which was of course flagged by the lino) was after about 25 minutes, despite numerous tugs, holding downs and climbings. Not that Plymouth were a dirty side, they were just common or garden fouls. He also missed some of those we committed, but spotted many more! He seemed to feel the need to have a word with any offending player no matter how trivial the offence. Later in the game he started giving 'fouls' that were either nowhere near as obvious as ones he'd let go before or not fouls at all, just players challenging for the ball.
I don't think there were any major decisions he had to make one way or the other (it was match played in a good spirit) - although that tackle late on was a borderline red IMO - so I don't think he affected the result really. I dread to think how he'd handle a game that was a bit more 'feisty'!